Penicillin Cocktail Recipe with Smoky Scotch, Honey, and Ginger

Published On: November 19, 2026

Table of Contents

Love a whiskey cocktail with a little sweetness and a smoky kick? This Penicillin cocktail recipe brings together honey, fresh lemon and spicy ginger in one refreshing drink.

The real magic comes from the peaty Scotch poured on top. It adds a smoky aroma that makes every sip taste a little different.

You don’t need fancy bartending skills to make it at home. Just prepare the honey-ginger syrup ahead of time and the rest comes together in minutes.

Ready to mix one for yourself? Grab your Scotch and cocktail shaker, and follow these simple steps to get the balance of sweet, sour and smoky flavors just right.

What is a Penicillin Cocktail?

A Penicillin is a modern Scotch cocktail made with blended Scotch, fresh lemon juice, and honey-ginger syrup. A small float of peated Islay Scotch sits on top. That peat smoke is one of the clearest scotch vs whiskey differences.

Australian bartender Sam Ross created it in 2005 at Milk & Honey, a well-known cocktail bar in New York City.

He built it as a variation on the Gold Rush, a popular house drink made with bourbon, lemon, and honey. Ross replaced the bourbon with blended Scotch and divided the sweetness between honey and ginger.

A fresh delivery of Compass Box whiskies helped inspire Ross to add the smoky Scotch float. He poured a small amount of Compass Box Peat Monster, a smoky blended malt, creating the signature smoky aroma.

The name Penicillin is a playful nod to the honey, lemon, and ginger flavors associated with traditional home remedies. The cocktail is enjoyed for its balance of sweetness, spice, citrus and smoky whisky.

Penicillin Cocktail Ingredients

This Penicillin cocktail recipe makes one drink. Your base bottle will say blended Scotch whisky, a term set by federal rules for Scotch.

Ingredient

Amount

Blended Scotch

2 oz or 60 ml

Fresh lemon juice

¾ oz or 22 ml

Honey-ginger syrup

¾ oz or 22 ml

Peated Islay single malt Scotch

¼ oz or about 7 ml

Ice cubes

As needed

Candied ginger

About a 1-inch piece, for garnish

Lemon peel

Optional

A Penicillin is a fairly strong cocktail. With 2 oz of blended Scotch and a ¼ oz Islay float, the finished drink is roughly 15-20% ABV, depending on the whisky strength and how much ice melts during shaking.

Pro Tip: Squeeze the lemon right before you mix. Fresh juice tastes much brighter than bottled, so strain out the seeds and pulp first.

Tools and Glassware You Need

You don’t need a full home bar for this drink. A few kitchen basics will handle the measuring, shaking, and smoky float. A rocks glass with one large ice cube works best. Big ice melts slowly, so your drink stays cold without getting watery too fast.

  • Cocktail shaker or a clean jar with a tight lid

  • Jigger or a small measuring cup with ounce marks

  • Cocktail strainer or a small kitchen strainer

  • Rocks glass

  • Bar spoon, or a regular teaspoon for the float

  • Citrus juicer

  • Small saucepan and a fine strainer for the syrup

Tip: Use a rocks or Old Fashioned glass for a classic Penicillin, a highball suits soda-topped versions, while a coupe works but chills less slowly.

Making Honey-Ginger Syrup for Penicillin

This syrup gives the Penicillin its spicy heat and sweetness. Ginger is the big change from the classic Gold Rush cocktail, which uses plain honey syrup. One batch makes enough for close to 20 drinks, so you won’t need to make it often.

Choose mild honey, such as clover or wildflower, to keep the ginger flavor balanced. Combine honey, water, and thinly sliced ginger in a small saucepan. Bring to a boil, then reduce the heat and simmer for 5 minutes.

Let the mixture cool completely before covering and refrigerating overnight. This allows the ginger flavor to develop.

Strain into a clean, airtight jar and refrigerate for up to one week. For conservative storage, use it within one week. Short on time? Ross’s original used honey syrup plus sweetened fresh ginger juice, which skips the overnight wait.

You need just three ingredients for one batch:

  • Honey: 1 cup

  • Water: 1 cup

  • Fresh ginger: One 6-inch piece, peeled and thinly sliced

How To Make a Penicillin Cocktail

The method is similar to a whiskey sour recipe, with Scotch, citrus and syrup shaken over ice. The final smoky float is what gives the Penicillin its signature finish.

Step 1: Chill The Glass

Adding clear ice cubes to a rocks glass for a Penicillin cocktail

Time: 1 minute | What You Need: Rocks glass, large ice cube

Drop one large ice cube into a rocks glass and set it aside. A cold glass keeps the drink crisp from the first sip.

A large ice cube melts more slowly, keeping the cocktail cold without watering it down too quickly. Smaller cubes or crushed ice chill the drink faster but also melt faster. Regular ice cubes work well if you don’t have a large ice mold.

Keep a few large cubes ready in a silicone mold. Store them in a sealed bag so they don’t pick up freezer smells.

Step 2: Measure The Liquids

Measuring Scotch whisky, fresh lemon juice, and honey-ginger syrup for a Penicillin cocktail

Time: 1 minute | What You Need: Jigger, cocktail shaker

Pour ¾ ounce of honey-ginger syrup and ¾ ounce of fresh lemon juice into the shaker. Then add 2 ounces of blended Scotch, one of the smoothest blended whiskey types.

Keep the Islay Scotch aside for now. It goes on top at the very end, so it never touches the shaker.

Measure the syrup before the Scotch. Measuring the Scotch next rinses the jigger and carries every sticky drop of honey into the shaker.

Step 3: Shake with Ice

Shaking Scotch whisky, lemon juice, and honey-ginger syrup in a cocktail shaker

Time: 10 to 15 seconds | What You Need: Ice, sealed shaker

Fill the shaker about three-quarters full with ice. Close it tightly and shake hard until the outside feels frosty.

The ice chills the drink and adds a little water. That water softens the alcohol and pulls the honey and lemon together.

Hold the shaker with both hands, one on each end. Your palms keep the lid sealed, even when the metal gets icy.

Step 4: Strain Over Fresh Ice

Straining the golden Penicillin cocktail mixture into a rocks glass over fresh ice

Time: 20 seconds | What You Need: Strainer, chilled rocks glass

Hold the strainer over the shaker and pour the drink into your chilled glass. The fresh ice keeps it from tasting thin.

For a clearer drink, double-strain through a cocktail strainer and a fine-mesh strainer. This catches small ice shards left after shaking and any ginger fibers that may have slipped through the syrup.

Leave a little space at the top of the glass. The Islay float needs room to sit on the surface without spilling.

Step 5: Float The Islay Scotch

Pouring Islay Scotch over a bar spoon to create a smoky float on a Penicillin cocktail

Time: 20 seconds | What You Need: Bar spoon, ¼ oz Islay Scotch

Hold a bar spoon upside down above the surface of the drink. Slowly pour the Islay Scotch over the back of the spoon.

The spoon slows the pour, so the Scotch stays on top. Don’t stir afterward. Sam Ross served it without a straw so the smoke reaches your nose first.

Measure the ¼ ounce in a jigger first. Free-pouring from the bottle usually adds too much.

Step 6: Garnish and Serve

Finishing a Penicillin cocktail with candied ginger and a lemon peel garnish

Time: 30 seconds | What You Need: Candied ginger, cocktail pick

Spear a piece of candied ginger on a cocktail pick and rest it across the glass. It gives you a sweet, chewy bite between sips.

Serve the drink right away. The smoky aroma fades the longer it sits, and the ice slowly thins the flavor.

Candied ginger is sold in most grocery stores near the dried fruit. Store-bought pieces work just as well as homemade.

Penicillin Cocktail Variations

The Penicillin is easy to play with. Change one thing at a time so the sweet, sour, and smoky parts stay in balance. Try the classic version first. That way, you can tell exactly what each swap changes.

1. Gold Rush: This is the drink that inspired the Penicillin. Shake 2 ounces of bourbon with ¾ ounce each of lemon juice and honey syrup.

2. Hot Penicillin: Combine 2 oz blended Scotch, 4 oz hot apple cider, ½ oz fresh lemon juice and ½ oz honey syrup in a heatproof mug. Stir gently and top with 1 oz ginger beer, then serve warm. Avoid boiling the Scotch to preserve its flavor.

3. Rum Penicillin: Replace the blended Scotch with 2 oz of aged rum. Add ¾ oz fresh lemon juice and reduce the honey-ginger syrup to ½ oz. Shake with ice, then float ¼ oz Islay Scotch for a smoky touch.

4. Mezcal Float: Replace the Islay Scotch with ¼ ounce of mezcal. You still get smoke, but it tastes earthier and more vegetal.

5. Bourbon Penicillin: Use 2 oz bourbon, ¾ oz fresh lemon juice, and ¾ oz honey-ginger syrup. Shake with ice and finish with a ¼ oz Islay Scotch float. Bourbon adds vanilla and caramel notes while keeping the smoky finish.

6. Penicillin Highball: Pour the shaken drink into a tall glass with ice. Top it with ginger ale or soda water for a lighter sip.

7. Non-alcoholic Penicillin: Replace the Scotch with 2 oz of strong chilled ginger tea. Add ¾ oz lemon juice and ½ oz honey syrup, then shake with ice. For a smoky finish, add a small splash of chilled lapsang souchong tea. Adjust the honey to taste.

What to Serve with a Penicillin Cocktail

The Penicillin’s sweet, citrusy and smoky flavors pair well with savory snacks and lightly spiced foods. There are a few options worth trying.

  • Smoked Salmon: Its smoky, salty flavor works well with the Scotch and fresh lemon.

  • Sharp Cheddar: The cheese’s rich, tangy taste balances the honey syrup.

  • Roasted Nuts: Salted almonds or cashews make an easy snack alongside the drink.

  • Barbecue: Grilled chicken or smoky ribs pair well with the ginger and peated Scotch.

  • Ginger Cookies: Their warm spice brings out the ginger flavor in the cocktail.

Final Thoughts

A great Penicillin comes down to three things: steeped ginger syrup, freshly squeezed lemon and a slow, smoky float.

Make the syrup a day early and each drink takes about three minutes. Start with the classic measurements of 2, ¾, ¾, and ¼ ounces. After that, adjust the syrup or the float on your next round until the drink tastes right to you.

When I made this, I paired Monkey Shoulder blended Scotch with Laphroaig 10 for the smoky float. I kept the honey-ginger syrup slightly less sweet so the fresh lemon and ginger could stand out without the smoke taking over.

Mix one at home this weekend, then share your favorite Scotch pairing or creative twist in the comments.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can You Make Penicillins Ahead for a Party?

Yes. Mix the Scotch and syrup in a sealed bottle a day ahead. Add the lemon juice a few hours before guests arrive, then shake and float each drink individually.

Can You Use Lime Instead of Lemon?

You can, but the drink will taste sharper and slightly more tropical. Lemon pairs better with honey and Scotch, so try the original version first.

Is a Penicillin Shaken or Stirred?

A Penicillin is always shaken. Cocktails with citrus juice need a hard shake to combine, chill, and develop a light, frothy texture.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Author

Hi, I’m James Harlow, and I write about creative cocktails, food pairings, and inspired drink recipes that elevate any occasion. From timeless classics to innovative seasonal creations, I focus on practical, flavorful ideas that readers can easily recreate at home. With years of hands-on bartending experience in lively restaurants and mixology events. I blend technique with fun storytelling to make entertaining effortless and delicious.

Table of Contents

Read More

paperclip
paperclip

The Godfather cocktail recipe proves a great drink doesn’t need many ingredients. Just Scotch and amaretto create a rich flavor

paperclip

A Sea Breeze keeps cocktail making straightforward while still offering a distinct fruit-forward taste. Vodka creates the base, while cranberry

KEEP SIPPING

Miller Lite is a familiar name for anyone who enjoys light beer, but many drinkers still want to know how

Domestic beer is one of the most common choices, but not every option tastes the same or delivers the same

Ever thought why the same beer tastes different depending on the glass it is poured into? The shape controls how

What are You Looking For?